As we continue to discuss Step 9: "Counsel mothers on the risks of feeding bottles, teats, and pacifier" of the Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding, the topic of nipple confusion arises. This topic has multiple names (nipple confusion, nipple preference, flow preference, etc.) and has been disputed in the literature for years. The most widely cited definition comes from Neifert et al (1995) which divides nipple confusion into two types.
Type A describes a neonate's difficulty in establishing the necessary oral configuration, latching technique and sucking pattern to extract milk from the breast after exposure to an artificial teat. Type B refers to older infants who have already established breastfeeding but begin to refuse the breast or prefer the bottle.
Since 1995, various studies have trialed oral configuration, bottle nipple flow rates, comparison between feeding at the breast or at the bottle, and many other theories to "prove or disprove” the existence of nipple confusion. Most IBCLCs who work with newborns have noted the difficulty for many infants under 28 days to have the skills to vary back and forth between latching well at the breast and latching well at a bottle.
At this point in time, the World Health Organization along with the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine and most countries' health provision boards recommend avoidance of any type of artificial nipple/teat prior to 4 weeks of infant age or until breastfeeding is well established.
Clinical Protocol #3 from the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine for Supplementary Feedings in the Healthy Term Breastfed Neonate (2017) states;
When supplementary feeding is medically necessary, the primary goals are to feed the infant and to optimize the maternal milk supply while determining the cause of low milk supply, poor feeding, or inadequate milk transfer. Supplementation should be performed in ways that help preserve breastfeeding such as limiting the volume to what is necessary for the normal newborn physiology, avoiding teats/artificial nipples, stimulating the mother's breasts with hand expression or pumping and for the infant to continue to practice at the breast.
And the American Academy of Pediatrics, who endorsed the Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding program in 2009, reinforced the avoidance of pacifiers and artificial nipples/teats in the neonate during the postpartum period.
In your healthcare and birthing centers, what do you see as a problem in giving newborn infants bottles, pacifiers or artificial teats? Is this an on-going problem for you? Have you changed that practice over time, and if so, how did you accomplish it?
These referenced documents might be a beginning for a staff inservice to help change policies and procedures. Be sure to find the healthcare documents for your country to add to these. And then let me know how you're doing!
Kathy Parkes, MSN-Ed, RN, IBCLC, FILCA CHC
Professional Development Educator
Zimmerman, E. and Thompson, K. (2015). Clarifying nipple confusion. Journal of Perinatology; 1-5.
Kellams, A., Harrel, C., Omage, S., Gregory, C., Rosen-Carole, C., and the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine. (2017). ABM Clinical Protocol #3: Supplementary feedings in the healthy term breastfed neonate. Breastfeeding Medicine; 12(3): 1-11. https://www.bfmed.org/protocols
American Academy of Pediatrics, Section on Breastfeeding. (2012). Breastfeeding and the use of human milk. Pediatrics; 129: e827. https://abm.memberclicks.net/assets/DOCUMENTS/PROTOCOLS/3-supplementation-protocol-english.pdf
When you visit the Site, we automatically collect certain information about your device, including information about your web browser, IP address, time zone, and some of the cookies that are installed on your device. Additionally, as you browse the Site, we collect information about the individual web pages or products that you view, what websites or search terms referred you to the Site, and information about how you interact with the Site. We refer to this automatically-collected information as Device Information."
We collect Device Information using the following technologies:
Additionally when you make a purchase or attempt to make a purchase through the Site, we collect certain information from you, including your name, billing address, shipping address, payment information (including credit card numbers), email address, and phone number. We refer to this information as "Order Information."
We use the Order Information that we collect generally to fulfill any orders placed through the Site (including processing your payment information, arranging for shipping, and providing you with invoices and/or order confirmations). Additionally, we use this Order Information to:
We use Student Access Information to provide accurate tracking to Users and Clients on completion and use of the courses, as well as for analysis on how to improve our services.
We use the Device Information that we collect to help us screen for potential risk and fraud (in particular, your IP address), and more generally to improve and optimize our Site (for example, by generating analytics about how our customers browse and interact with the Site, and to assess the success of our marketing and advertising campaigns).
We share your Personal Information with third parties to help us use your Personal Information, as described above. For example, with your employer who needs to verify your completion or progress of your studies. We also use Google Analytics to help us understand how our customers use the Site--you can read more about how Google uses your Personal Information here: https://www.google.com/intl/en/policies/privacy/. You can also opt-out of Google Analytics here: https://tools.google.com/dlpage/gaoptout.
Finally, we may also share your Personal Information to comply with applicable laws and regulations, to respond to a subpoena, search warrant or other lawful request for information we receive, or to otherwise protect our rights.
As described above, we use your Personal Information to provide you with targeted advertisements or marketing communications we believe may be of interest to you. For more information about how targeted advertising works, you can visit the Network Advertising Initiative's ("NAI") educational page at https://www.networkadvertising.org/understanding-online-advertising/how-does-it-work.
You can opt out of targeted advertising by:
Additionally, you can opt out of some of these services by visiting the Digital Advertising Alliance's opt-out portal at: http://optout.aboutads.info.
Please note that we do not alter our Site's data collection and use practices when we see a Do Not Track signal from your browser.
If you are a European resident, you have the right to access personal information we hold about you and to ask that your personal information be corrected, updated, or deleted. If you would like to exercise this right, please contact us through the contact information below.
Additionally, if you are a European resident we note that we are processing your information in order to fulfill contracts we might have with you (for example if you make an order through the Site), or otherwise to pursue our legitimate business interests listed above. Additionally, please note that your information will be transferred outside of Europe, including to Canada and the United States.
When you place an order through the Site, we will maintain your Order Information and Student Access Information for our records unless and until you ask us to delete this information. We are required to keep course completion records for at least 5 years in order to comply with certain accreditation requirements.
For more information about our privacy practices, if you have questions, or if you would like to make a complaint, please contact us by e-mail at firstname.lastname@example.org or by mail using the details provided below:
5890 Monkland Avenue, #16, Montreal, QC, H4A 1G2, Canada
Last Updated: September 2018